After being drafted 20th overall in the first round of the 2022 MLS SuperDraft from Florida Gulf Coast University, O’Vonte Mullings spent two seasons with the New York Red Bulls – captaining the New York Red Bulls II, as well as with the first team. Mullings managed to play 56 games for the New York Red Bulls II, where he scored 6 goals and 11 assists. He also appeared in 3 games for the New York Red Bulls and made his MLS debut on May 18, 2023 against Toronto FC.